How to Write "Why This College" Essays That Actually Work
Every selective college asks "Why us?" Most students give generic answers. Here's the research-backed formula that makes admissions officers say "This student gets it."
The Truth About "Why Us" Essays
Admissions officers can tell when you're using ChatGPT or copy-pasting from the website. They read hundreds of these essays. 95% say the exact same things: "beautiful campus," "world-class professors," "diverse community."
This guide shows you how to write the other 5%—the essays that actually demonstrate fit.
The Formula That Works (For Any School)
The 3-Part Structure:
WHO YOU ARE
Start with a specific interest, goal, or value that you have. Make it concrete—not "I love learning" but "I'm obsessed with urban planning policy."
WHY THIS SCHOOL
Connect your interest to 3-5 specific, unique things about the school. Not generic stuff—specific classes, professors, programs, or opportunities you can't get elsewhere.
WHAT YOU'LL CONTRIBUTE
End by showing what you'll add to campus. How will you engage with these opportunities? What will you bring to the community?
In one sentence: "Because of [WHO YOU ARE], I'm excited about [SPECIFIC THINGS AT SCHOOL], where I'll [CONTRIBUTE/ENGAGE]."
Key Insight:
The best "Why Us" essays are actually "Why Me + You" essays. They show fit in both directions: why the school matches your goals and why you match the school's culture.
How to Research (Beyond the Website)
Everyone reads the admissions website. That's why everyone writes the same essay. Here's where to find the specific details that make your essay stand out:
1. Course Catalog Deep Dive
Go to the actual course catalog (not admissions site). Find specific classes that excite you.
✓ Good: "Prof. Chen's 'Urban Inequality' course combines sociology and GIS mapping"
✗ Bad: "Great sociology department"
2. Professor Research
Find 1-2 professors whose work aligns with your interests. Read their recent papers/projects.
✓ Good: "Prof. Wang's research on climate migration patterns"
✗ Bad: "World-renowned faculty"
3. Student Clubs/Organizations
Look at student org websites. Find specific clubs/projects you'd join.
✓ Good: "The Code4Good hackathon team building apps for nonprofits"
✗ Bad: "Many clubs to join"
4. Unique Programs/Centers
Find programs that exist ONLY at this school or are distinctly different.
✓ Good: "The Social Innovation Incubator's partnership with local startups"
✗ Bad: "Great internship opportunities"
5. Student Newspapers/Blogs
Read the student newspaper. See what students actually care about and discuss.
✓ Good: "The recent symposium on AI ethics"
✗ Bad: "Intellectual community"
6. Talk to Current Students
DM students on LinkedIn or Instagram. Ask about their favorite class or experience.
✓ Good: "Maria told me about the collaborative senior thesis process"
✗ Bad: Generic statements with no sourcing
Pro Tip: The "Only Here" Test
For each thing you mention, ask: "Could I say this about another school?" If yes, it's too generic. Keep digging until you find details unique to THIS school.
What Works vs. What Doesn't
WORKS (Specific & Genuine)
- ✓ Naming specific courses with course numbers
- ✓ Mentioning professors + their research
- ✓ Describing unique programs/centers
- ✓ Referencing specific student orgs/publications
- ✓ Connecting school features to YOUR goals
- ✓ Showing you've researched beyond rankings
- ✓ Demonstrating cultural fit with specifics
DOESN'T WORK (Generic)
- ✗ "World-class faculty"
- ✗ "Beautiful campus"
- ✗ "Diverse student body"
- ✗ "Great location"
- ✗ "Strong [major] program"
- ✗ "Small class sizes"
- ✗ Just listing departments/majors
Before & After: Real Examples
❌ BEFORE (Generic):
"I want to attend Northwestern because of its world-class journalism program. The beautiful campus near Chicago provides great opportunities. I'm excited to learn from renowned professors and join the diverse community. The strong academic reputation and school spirit make it my top choice."
Why it fails:
- • Could describe 50 other schools
- • No specific professors, courses, or programs
- • Doesn't show research or genuine interest
✅ AFTER (Specific):
"As an aspiring investigative journalist focused on environmental policy, I'm drawn to Medill's Environmental Journalism focus under Professor Ellen Shearer. Her work exposing corporate pollution aligns with my reporting on local water quality. I'd join North by Northwestern to cover sustainability issues, and Northwestern's quarter system would let me combine journalism courses with environmental science classes—exactly the interdisciplinary approach I need to tell data-driven environmental stories."
Why it works:
- • Names specific professor + her work
- • Mentions student publication by name
- • Connects quarter system to specific goals
- • Shows previous relevant experience
7 Fatal Mistakes (That Kill Most Essays)
Mistake #1: Name-Dropping Without Connection
Problem: Listing famous professors or programs without explaining WHY they matter to YOU.
Fix: For everything you mention, add 'which aligns with my interest in [specific thing].'
Mistake #2: The Flattery Trap
Problem: Spending the whole essay praising the school ('You're so great!').
Fix: Focus on FIT, not flattery. Show what you'll DO there, not just what they have.
Mistake #3: The Rankings Mention
Problem: Mentioning US News rankings, prestige, or brand name.
Fix: Never mention rankings. Focus on specific programs and opportunities instead.
Mistake #4: The Copy-Paste Website Job
Problem: Paraphrasing the admissions website or course descriptions.
Fix: Go beyond the website. Use course catalogs, student newspapers, professor pages.
Mistake #5: Forgetting 'Why YOU'
Problem: Essay is all about the school, nothing about what YOU bring.
Fix: End with specific ways you'll contribute—clubs you'll join, projects you'll start.
Mistake #6: Generic Major Declaration
Problem: 'I want to major in biology at your great biology program.'
Fix: Mention specific research areas, labs, or interdisciplinary combinations.
Mistake #7: The Laundry List
Problem: Just listing 10 different things without depth.
Fix: Pick 3-5 things and explain WHY each one matters. Depth > breadth.
Fill-in-the-Blank Template (Emergency Use Only)
Use this as a starting point, then customize heavily:
As someone passionate about [YOUR SPECIFIC INTEREST], I'm drawn to [SCHOOL]'s [SPECIFIC PROGRAM/CENTER/OPPORTUNITY]. In particular, I'm excited about [SPECIFIC COURSE/PROFESSOR'S WORK], which connects to [YOUR PAST EXPERIENCE/GOAL].
Beyond academics, I'd contribute to [SPECIFIC CLUB/ORGANIZATION], where I could [SPECIFIC CONTRIBUTION]. Additionally, [ANOTHER UNIQUE FEATURE] would allow me to [SPECIFIC GOAL/ACTION].
What excites me most is [SPECIFIC CULTURAL/PHILOSOPHICAL FIT], which aligns with my belief that [YOUR VALUES/APPROACH].
Final Thoughts
The "Why Us" essay is actually a gift. It's your chance to show admissions officers that you've done your homework and genuinely understand what makes their school special.
The secret? These essays aren't about convincing them you're good enough for their school. They're about showing them that their school is the right fit for YOUR specific goals.
Bottom line: Spend 2-3 hours researching each school. Your essay will write itself once you find those specific, unique details that genuinely excite you.
Writing Multiple "Why Us" Essays? Get Expert Help
Most students apply to 8-12 schools. That's 8-12 different "Why Us" essays. Get all your supplements reviewed by experts from top universities—we offer bulk pricing.
Save money reviewing multiple supplements
Reviewers who got into YOUR target schools
3-5 day turnaround on all essays
✅ School-specific feedback • ✅ Research suggestions included • ✅ 7-day guarantee